REVIEW ON COLUMN FIRE RESISTANCE DESIGN FOR CONCRETE FILLED STEEL TUBE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11113/jt.v80.11114Keywords:
Fire resistance, concrete filled steel tube, column, foamed concreteAbstract
The use of concrete filled steel tube (CFST) columns offers an alternative for providing the required fire resistance and load bearing capacity, making its use in medium and high rise structures are highly popular. This paper aims to review the previous studies on CFST column under fire. The standards or codes of practice used in fire resistance designs have been highlighted. The design of the CFST column is summarised with previous investigations on experiments and numerical modelling at ambient temperature and elevated temperature. Different conclusions were drawn depending on the material’s properties, considered parameters and the method used for the investigations. Outer diameter or width of the steel tube, steel tube thickness, concrete grade, column length, and eccentricity of loadings are among the parameters that affects the structural behaviour of CFST columns under fire. Several numerical analyses software were adequately used for simulating the behaviour of CFST columns at elevated temperatures, and validated using experimental results. Furthermore, the advantages of using the fire resistance design approaches on CFST columns filled with lightweight foamed concrete is highlighted. In conclusion, there is the need for more studies on standard fire tests of CFST column filled with light weight foamed concrete which is not covered in the current design guide.
References
FEMA. 2002. World Trade Center Building Performance Study: Data Collection, Preliminary Observation, and Recommendations. Federal Emergencu Management Agency (FEMA), Federal Insurance and Mitigation Administration, Washington, DC.
Beitel, J. J. & Iwankiw, N. R. 2006. Historical Survey of Multi-story Building Collapse Due to Fire. White Papers of Jensen Hughes. Retrieved on 28 April 2016 from http://www.jensenhughes.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/White_Paper_Historical_Survey_Building_Collapse_NIST_JBeitel-NIwankiw_OCT-2006.pdf.
Scott, D., Lane, B. and Gibbons, C. Fire Induced Progressive Collapse. Proceedings of the Workshop on Prevention of Progressive Collapse, Multihazard Mitigation Council of the National Institute of Building Sciences, Rosemont, Il, July 10-12, 2002. Retrieved on 28 April 2014 from https://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.nibs.org/resource/resmgr/MMC/wppc_scott_paper.pdf.
L. Twilt, R. Hass, W. Klingsch, M. Edwards, and D. Dutta. 1994. Design Guide for Structural Hollow Section Columns Exposed to Fire. Verlag TUV Rheinland GmbH, CIDECT, Koln Germany. 16-18.
Hung, W. Y. and Chow, W. K. 2002. Review on the Requirements on Fire Resisting Construction. International Journal of Engineering Performance-based Fire Codes. 4(3): 68-83.
Barry, C. 2007. Fire Inside: Structural Design with Fire Safety in Mind. Science News. 172: 122-124.
Petterson. O., Magnusson. S. and Thor. J. 1976. Fire Engineering of Steel Structures. Publication 50, Swedish Institute of Steel Construction, Stockholm.
Kodur, V., Garlock, M. and Iwankiw, Nestor. 2007. National Workshop on Structures in Fire: State-of-the-Art, Research and Training Needs. Grant Report: CEE-RR-2007/03, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan.
Iwankiw, N., Beyler, C. 2016. New Standards for Engineering Design of Structural Fire Protection. SFPE Fire Protection Engineering eNewsletter, Issue 79. Retrieved on 9 May 2016 from http://www.sfpe.org/page/FPE_ET_Issue_79/New-Standards-for-Engineering-Design-of-Structural-Fire-Protection.htm.
Morris, W. A., Read, R. E. H and Cooke, G. M. E. 1988. Guidelines for the Construction of Fire-resisting Structural Elements. Building Research Establishment, UK.
Kirby, B. R. 1998. The Behavior of a Multi-storey Steel Framed Building Subjected to Fire Attack. British Steel plc, Swinden Technology Centre, UK.
NFPA. 2006. Standard Methods of Tests of Fire Resistance of Building Construction and Materials. Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA, US. NFPA 251.
NFPA. 2015. Standard on Types of Building Construction. Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA. NFPA 220.
NFPA. 2015. Building Construction and Safety Code. Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA. NFPA 5000.
NFPA. 2006. Standard Method of Test of Surface Burning Characteristics of Building Materials. Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA. NFPA 255.
NFPA. 2013. Standard Test Method for Potential Heat of Building Materials. Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA. NFPA 259.
British Standard Institute. 2009. BS 476: Fire Tests on Building Materials and Structures – Part 10: Guide to the Principles, Selection, Role and Application of Fire Testing and Their Outputs. London:BSI. BS476-10.
British Standard Institute. 1987. BS 476: Fire Tests on Building Materials and Structures – Part 20: Method for Determination of the Fire Resistance of Elements of Construction (General Principles). London:BSI. BS476-20.
British Standard Institute. 1987. BS 476: Fire Tests on Building Materials and Structures – Part 21: Methods for Determination of the Fire Resistance of Loadbearing Elements of Construction. London:BSI. BS476-21.
British Standard Institute. 1987. BS 476: Fire Tests on Building Materials and Structures – Part 22: Methods for Determination of the Fire Resistance of Non-Loadbearing Elements of Construction. London:BSI. BS476-22.
British Standard Institute. 1987. BS 476: Fire Tests on Building Materials and Structures – Part 23: Methods for Determination of the Contribution of Components to the Fire Resistance of a Structure. London:BSI. BS476-23.
British Standard Institute. 2012. BS EN1363 - Fire Resistance Tests: Part 1: General Requirements. London:BSI. BS EN1363-1.
British Standard Institute. 1999. BS EN1363 - Fire Resistance Tests: Part 2: Alternative and Additional Procedures. London:BSI. BS EN1363-2.
British Standard Institute. 2014. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 1: Horizontal Protective Membranes. London:BSI. BS EN13381-1.
British Standard Institute. 2014. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 2: Vertical Protective Membranes. London:BSI. BS EN13381-2.
British Standard Institute. 2015. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 3: Applied Protection to Concrete Members. London:BSI. BS EN13381-3.
British Standard Institute. 2013. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 4: Applied Passive Protection to Steel Members. London:BSI. BS EN13381-4.
British Standard Institute. 2014. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 5: Applied Protection to Concrete/Profiled Sheet Steel Composite Member. London:BSI. BS EN13381-5.
British Standard Institute. 2012. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 6: Applied Protection to Concrete Filled Hollow Steel Columns. London:BSI. BS EN13381-6.
British Standard Institute. 2002. Draft for Development ENV13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 7: Applied Protection to Timber Members. London:BSI. DD ENV13381-7.
British Standard Institute. 2013. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 8: Applied Reactive Protection to Steel Members. London:BSI. BS EN13381-8.
British Standard Institute. 2015. BS EN13381 – Test Methods for Determining the Contribution to the Fire Resistance of Structural Members – Part 9: Applied Fire Protection Systems to Steel Beams With Web Openings. London:BSI. BS EN13381-9.
International Organization for Standardization. 1999. ISO834 – Fire Resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 1: General Requirements. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-1.
International Organization for Standardization. 2000. ISO834 – Fire Resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 4: Specific Requirements For Loadbearing Vertical Separating Elements. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-4.
International Organization for Standardization. 2000. ISO834 – Fire resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 5: Specific Requirements for Loadbearing Horizontal Separating Elements. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-5.
International Organization for Standardization. 2000. ISO834 – Fire Resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 6: Specific Requirements for Beams. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-6.
International Organization for Standardization. 2000. ISO834 – Fire Resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 7: Specific Requirements for Columns. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-7.
International Organization for Standardization. 2014. ISO834 – Fire Resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 10: Specific Requirements to Determine the Contribution of Applied Fire Protection Materials to Structural Steel Elements. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-10.
International Organization for Standardization. 2014. ISO834 – Fire Resistance Tests – Elements of Building Construction – Part 11: Specific Requirements for the Assessment of Fire Protection to Structural Steel Elements. Geneva:ISO. ISO834-11.
Australia Standard Committee. 2005. AS1530 – Methods for Fire Tests on Building Materials, Components and Structures – Part 4: Fire-Resistance Test of Elements of Construction. Sydney:ASC. AS1530-4.
Standard & Industrial Research Institute of Malaysia. 1996. MS1073 – Method for Determination of the Fire Resistance – Part 2: General Principle. Malaysia:SIRIM. MS1073-2.
Bureau of Indian Standards. 1979, Reaffirmed in 2002. IS3809 – Fire Resistance Test of Structures. New Delhi:BIS. IS3809.
American National Standards Institute. 2011. UL263 – Standard for Fire Tests of Building Construction and Materials. North America:ANSI. UL263.
Rackliffe, C. A. (996. Performance-based Building Codes: The United Kingdom Experience. International Conference on Performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Hunt, J. H. 1996. Performance-based Codes: The New Zealand Experience. International Conference on Performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Johnsson, Rand Rantatalo, T. 1996. Performance-based Codes: The Swedish Experience. International Conference on Performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Bowen, N. 1996. The Performance Building Code of Australia. A Study of its Development. International Conference on performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Thomas, R and Bowen, R. 1996. Objective-based Codes: The Canadian Direction. International Conference on Performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Nakaya, I and Hirano, Y. 1996. Japan's Approach toward the Building Code and Standards. International Conference on Performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Traw, J. S. 1996. Future Prospective of the U.S. Model Building Codes. International Conference on Performance-based Codes and Fire Safety Design Methods, Sept. 24-26, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, SFPE, Boston, MA.
Bukowski, R. W. 1995. International Activities for Developing Performance-based Fire Codes. Fire Safety Design of Buildings and Fire Safety Engineering. Proceedings of the Mini-Symposium June 12, Tsukuba Japan, Building Research Institute, MOC Japan. 25-27.
ASTM. 2016. E119 - Standard Test Methods for Fire Tests of Building Construction and Materials. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA. ASTM E119.
Beyler C, Beitel J., Iwankiw N., and Lattimer B. 2007. Fire Resistance Testing for Performance-based Fire Design of Buildings. Final Report for the Fire Protection Research Foundation, USA. HAI Project # 2843-000.
British Standard Institute. 2003. PD 7974 - Application of Fire Safety Engineering Principles to the Design of Buildings – Part 1: Initiation and Development of Fire within the Enclosure of Origin (Sub-system 1). London:BSI. PD7974-1.
British Standard Institute. 2002. BS EN1991 Eurocode 1: Actions on Structures – Part 1.2: General Actions - Actions on the structures exposed to fire. London:BSI. BS EN1991-1-2.
Australia Building Codes Board (ABCB). 2016. National Construction Code: Building Code of Australia – Class 2 to Class 0 Buildings. Canberra, Australia: ABCB.
Department of Building and Housing. 2005. Building Regulations 2004. Wellington, New Zealand: DBH.
National Research Council Canada. 2010. National Building Code of Canada. Canada: NRCC.
The Building Center of Japan (BCJ). 2015. The Building Standard Law of Japan. Japan: BCJ.
L. Twilt, R. Hass, W. Klingsch, M. Edwards and D. Dutta, 1996. Design Guide for Structural Hollow Sections Exposed to Fire, second edition. Germany:CIDECT Publications.
X.L. Zhao, L.H. Han and H. Lu. 2010. Concrete-filled Tubular Members and Connections. Taylor & Francis.
Wardenier, J. J. A. Packer, X.-L. Zhao and G.J. van der Vegte. 2010. Hollow Sections in Structural Applications. Netherlands: CIDECT.
Capilla, A. E. 2012. Numerical Analysis of the Fire Resistance of Circular and Elliptical Slender Concrete Filled Tubular Columns. PhD thesis. Valencia, Spain: Universitat Politecnica de Valencia.
Ikeda, K. and Y. Ohmiya. 2009. Fire Safety Engineering of Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Column without Protection. Fire Science and Technology. 28 (3): 106-131.
Kodur, V.K.R. and D.H. MacKinnon. 2000. Design of Concrete-Filled Hollow Structural Steel Columns for Fire Endurance. Engineering Journal. 37(1): 13-24.
Hicks, S. J. and G. M. Newman. 2002. Design Guide for Concrete Filled Columns. Berkshire:CORUS Tubes and Steel Construction Institute.
Schneider, S. P. 1998. Axially Loaded Concrete-filled Steel Tubes. Journal of Structural Engineering. 124(10): 1125–1138.
Huang, C. S., Yeh, Y. K., Hu, H. T., Tsai, K. C., Weng, Y. T., Wang, S. H. 2002. Axial Load Behavior of Stiffened Concrete-filled Steel Columns. Journal of Structural Engineering. 128(9): 1222-1230.
Sakino, K., Nakahara, H., Morino, S., Nishiyama, I. 2004. Behavior of Centrally Loaded Concrete-filled Steel-Tube Short Columns. Journal of Structural Engineering. 130(2): 180-188.
Giakoumelis, G., and Lam, D. 2004. Axial Capacity of Circular Concrete-filled Tube Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 60(7): 1049-1068.
Han, L. H, Liu, W., Yang, Y. F. 2008. Behaviour of Concrete-filled Steel Tubular Stub Columns Subjected to Axially Local Compression. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 64(4): 377-387.
Ellobody, E. Ghazy, M. F. 2012. Tests and Design of Stainless Steel Tubular Columns Filled with Polypropylene Fibre Reinforced Concrete. Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Advances in Steel Concrete Composite and Hybrid Structures, ASCCS. Singapore, 2–4 July, 2012.
Young B. and Ellobody E. 2006. Experimental Investigation of Concrete-filled Cold-formed High Strength Stainless Steel Tube Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 62(5): 484-492.
Lam D., Gardner L. 2008. Structural Design of Stainless Steel Concrete Filled Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 64(11): 1275-1282.
Ghannam, S.; Al-Ani, H, R.; Al-Rawi, O. 2010. Comparative Study of Load Carrying of Steel Tube Columns Filled with Light Weight Concrete and Normal Concrete. Jordan Journal of Civil Engineering. 4(2): 164-169.
Lie, T. T., R. J. Irwin, and M. Chabot. 1991. Factors Affecting the Fire Resistance of Circular Hollow Steel Columns Filled with Plain Concrete. IRC Internal Report 612. National Research Council of Canada.
Lie, T. T. and M. Chabot. 1992. Experimental Studies on the Fire Resistance of Hollow Steel Columns Filled with Plain Concrete. National Research Council Canada. 1992. Internal Report No. 611.
Lie, T. T. and Chabot, M. 1990. A Method to Predict the Fire Resistance of Circular Concrete Filled Hollow Steel Columns. Journal of Fire Protection Engineering. 2(4): 111-126.
Lie, T. T., Irwin, R. J. 1995. Fire Resistance of Rectangular Steel Columns Filled with Bar Reinforced Concrete. Journal of Structural Engineering. 121(5): 797-805.
Kodur, V. K. R. and T. T. Lie. 1995. Experimental Studies on the Fire Resistance of Circular Hollow Steel Columns Filled with Steel-Fibre-Reinforced Concrete. National Research Council Canada. Internal Report No. 691.
Kodur, V. K. R., and Lie, T. T. 1996. Fire Resistance Of Circular Steel Columns Filled With Fiber-Reinforced Concrete. Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE. 776-782.
Yin, J., Zha, X. X., Li L. Y. 2006. Fire Resistance of Axially Loaded Concrete Filled Steel Tube Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 62(7): 723-729.
Han, L. H., Yang, Y.F., Xu, L. 2003. An Experimental Study and Calculation on the Fire Resistance of Concrete-filled Square Hollow and Round Hollow Columns. Journal of Construction Steel Research. 59(4): 427-452.
Espinos, A., M. L. Romero, A. Hospitaler, C. Ibanez & A. Pascual. 2012. An Experimental Study of the Fire Behavior of Slender Concrete Filled Circular Hollow Section Columns. Proceedings of the 14th International Symposium on tubular structures, London, UK. 583-590.
Manuel, L. Romero, V. Moliner, A. Espinos, C. Ibanez, A. Hospitaler. 2011. Fire Behavior of Axially Loaded Slender High Strength Concrete-filled Tubular Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 67(12): 1953-1965.
Franssen, J. M. 2005. SAFIR: A Thermal/Structural Program for Modeling Structures Under Fire. Engineering Journal-American Institute of Steel Construction. 42(3): 143-158.
Dai X. H. & D. Lam. 2012. Shape Effect on Structural Fire Behaviour of Axially Loaded Concrete Filled Tubular (CFT) Stub Columns. Proceedings of the 14th international Symposium on Tubular Structures, London, UK, 12–14 September 2012.
Chen Shiming and Zhang Huifeng. 2012. Numerical Analysis of the Axially Loaded Concrete Filled Steel Tube Columns with De-Bonding Separation at the Steel-Concrete Interface. Steel and Composite Structures. 13(3): 277-293.
Z. Yang, Y. Zhang, M. Chen, G. Chen. 2013. Numerical Simulation of Ultra-strength Concrete-filled Steel Columns. Engineering Review. 33(3): 211-217.
Kodur, V. R. 1999. Performance-based Fire Resistance Design of Concrete-filled Steel Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 51(1): 21-36.
British Standard Institute. 2005. BS EN 1994 - Design of Composite Steel and Concrete Structures - Part 1-2: General Rules - Structural Fire Design. London, BS EN 1994-1-2.
Ding, J. and Y. C. Wang. 2008. Realistic Modelling of Thermal and Structural Behaviour of Unprotected Concrete Filled Tubular Columns in Fire. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 64(10): 1086-1102.
Schaumann, P., Kodur V. and Bahr O. 2009. Fire Behaviour of Hollow Structural Section Steel Columns Filled with High Strength Concrete. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 65(8-9): 1794-1802.
Chu, T. B. 2009. Hollow Steel Section Columns filled with Self-Compacting Concrete under Ordinary and Fire Conditions. Ph.D. University de Liege.
Song, T.Y., Han L. H. and Yu H. X. 2010. Concrete Filled Steel Tube Stub Columns under Combined Temperature and Loading. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 66(3): 369-384.
Espinos, A., Romero M. L. and Hospitaler A. 2010. Advanced Model for Predicting the Fire Response of Concrete Filled Tubular Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 66(8-9): 1030-1046.
Espinos, A., Gardner L., Romero M. L. and Hospitaler A. 2011. Fire Behaviour of Concrete Filled Elliptical Steel Columns. Thin-Walled Structures. 49(2): 239-255.
McGranttan, K. B., Klein B., Hostikka S. and Floyd J. 2002. Fire Dynamic Simulator (Version 5) User's Guide.User's guide. 3rd ed. Washington, National Institute of Standards and Technology.
Hong, S. 2007. Fundamental Behaviour and Stability of CFT Columns under Fire Loading. PhD thesis. Purdue University.
Hong, S. and A. H. Varma. 2009. Analytical Modelling of the Standard Fire Behavior of Loaded CFT Columns. Journal of Constructional Steel Research. 65(1): 54-69.
Chen, T. L. September 2006. Report on Position Paper on Safety against Fire in Buildings. In Jurutera: An Elevated View Of The KL Tower Surroundings. Bulletin of Institute Engineers Malaysia, IEM. 42.
David Rush. 2013. Fire Performance of Unprotected and Protected Concrete Filled Steel Hollow Structural Sections. PhD thesis University of Edinburgh. 25-27.
SIRIM QAS International. Fire Testing. Retrieved on 31 August 2016, from http://www.sirim-qas.com.my/index.php/en/our-services/product-testing/fire-protection-testing.
Shah M. F. Fire-testing Lab at UTM Can Test Various Kinds of Fire-Proof Materials. The Star Online News. 24 April 2014. Retrieved on 31 August 2016, from http://www.thestar.com.my/news/community/2014/04/24/boost-for-construction-firetesting-lab-at-utm-can-test-various-kinds-of-fireproof-materials/.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright of articles that appear in Jurnal Teknologi belongs exclusively to Penerbit Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (Penerbit UTM Press). This copyright covers the rights to reproduce the article, including reprints, electronic reproductions, or any other reproductions of similar nature.
