Effect of Flow Pattern at Pipe Bends on Corrosion Behaviour of Low Carbon Steek and its Challenges


  • Jamaluddin Md Sheriff Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia
  • Muhamadu Masin Muhammadu Department of Mechanical Engineering, Federal University of Technology, Minna
  • Esah Hamzah Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia




ALARP (As Low As Reasonably Practicable) Co2 corrosion, corrosion resistant alloy (CRA), decision gates, erosion-corrosion, life cycle performance, risk basis


Recent design work regarding seawater flow lines has emphasized the need to identify, develop, and verify critical relationships between corrosion prediction and flow regime mechanisms at pipe bend. In practice this often reduces to an pragmatic interpretation of the effects of corrosion mechanisms at pipe bends. Most importantly the identification of positions or sites, within the internal surface contact areas where the maximum corrosion stimulus may be expected to occur, thereby allowing better understanding, mitigation, monitoring and corrosion control over the life cycle. Some case histories have been reviewed in this context, and the interaction between corrosion mechanisms and flow patterns closely determined, and in some cases correlated. Since the actual relationships are complex, it was determined that a risk based decision making process using selected ‘what’ if corrosion analyses linked to ‘what if’ flow assurance analyses was the best way forward. Using this in methodology, and pertinent field data exchange, it is postulated that significant improvements in corrosion prediction can be made. This paper outlines the approach used and shows how related corrosion modelling software data such as that available from corrosion models Norsok  M5006, and Cassandra to parallel  computational flow modelling in a targeted manner can generate very noteworthy results, and considerably more viable trends for corrosion control guidance. It is postulated that the normally associated lack of agreement between corrosion modelling and field experience, is more likely due to inadequate consideration of corrosion stimulating flow regime data, rather than limitations of the corrosion modelling. Applications of flow visualization studies as well as computations with the k-  model of turbulence have identified flow features and regions where metal loss is a maximum.



Pourahamadi F. and Humphrey J. A. 1983. Physicsco Chem. Hydrodynamics. 4: 191.

Zeisei H. and Durst F. 1990. Computations of Erosion-corrosion Processes in Separated Two-phase Flows Corrosion/90. Paper no. 29. National Association of Corrosion Engineers, Houston, Texas.

Nesic S. and Postlethwatte J. 1990. Corrosion. 46: 874.

Nesic S. and Postlethwatte J. 1991. Can. Chem. Engineering. 69: 698.

Nesic S. and Postlethwatte J. 1991. Corrosion. 47: 582.

Nesic, Ph,D. 1991. Thesis, University of Saskatchewan, Sakatoon.

Roco M. C. 1990. Corrosion. 46: 424.

Blati M. and et– atel. 1989. Corrosion. 45: 793.

Lotz U. and Postlethwatte J. 1990. Corrosion Science. 30: 95.

Syderger T. and Lotz J. 1982. Electrochem Society. 129: 276.

Blatt W. and Hetz E. 1990. Hydromechanical Measurements for Erosion-corrosion. Corrosion/90, paper no. 25, National Association of Corrosion Engineers, Houston, Texas.

Nesic S., Postlethwatte J. and Bergstrom D. J. 1992. Int. J. Heat Transfer. 35.

Patankar S. V. 1990. Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow. New York: MCGraw Hill.

SinghB., Folk T., Jukes P., Garcia J., Perich, W. 2007. Engineering Pragmatic Solutions for CO2 Corrosion Problems, paper 07310 NACE Corrosion.

Olsen S. 2003. CO2 Corrosion Prediction by Use of Norsok M506 Model Guidelines and Limitations, paper 2336, NACE Corrosion.

Nybong R. 2003. Understanding and Prediction of Mesa Corrosion Attack, paper 42036 NACE Corrosion.

SinghB., Folk T., Jukes P., Garcia J., Perich W. 2006. Research in Progress Symposium, presentation, 06R206, NACE Corrosion.

Tang C., Ayello F., Cai J., Neisic S. 2006. Experimental Study on water wetting and CO2 Corrosion in Oil-water two phase flow, paper 06559, NACE Corrosion.

Nesij S., Cai J., Lee K. L. 2005. Multiphase Flow and Internal Corrosion Prediction Model for Mild Steel Pipeline, paper 06555, NACE Corrosion.

Poblete B., Singh B. 2005. Risk, Rust and Reliability, paper 05555, NACE Corrosion.

IONIK-J Kenny Reports. 2008. Internal Spreadsheetsand Toolboxes (2005-).

Norsok M506 Software and BP Cassandra Software Modelling and Support Literature (2003-2007).

Hedges B., Paisley D., Woollam R. 2001. The Corrosion Inhibitor Availability Model, paper 0043, NACE Corrosion.

Ai 14E RP, Offshore Piping Design Section 2.5, Version (1991).

IONIK Consulting T4B Private Venture Studies Materials, Corrosion Modelling, and Fitness for Service (2005-2007).

DNV RP 0501, Erosive Wear in Piping Systems 1999 (updated 2002).

Rippon I. 2001. Carbon Steel Pipeline Corrosion Engineering : Life Cycle Approach , paper 01055, NACE Corrosion.

Hedges B., Sprague K., Bieri T., Chen J. H., 2006. A Review of Monitoring and Inspection Techniques for CO2 and H2S Corrosion in Oil and Gas Production Facilities: Location, Location, Location paper 06120.

Deizell A, G. 2004. Inherently Safe Design paper 85698, Society of Petroleum Engineers, Convention.

Kelly G. 2006. IONIK Klips Internal Reliability and Integrity Study.

Nagano y., and Hishida M. 1987. ASME J. Fluids Engineering. 109: 156.

Laurder E. B. 1988. Trans. ASME J. Heat Transfer. 110: 1112.

Durst T., et-atel. 1984. Applied Mathematics Modelling. 8: 101.

Postlethwatte J., Nesic S., and Bergstrom D. J. 1998. Predictive Models for Erosion-Corrosion under Disturbed Flow Conditions. 1–4.

Singh B., Krishnathasan K. 2009. Making the Link between Inherently Safe Design, Integrity Management and Piping. The pipeline Pigging and Integrity Management Conference, Houston.

Singh B., Krishnathasan K. 2010. Pragmatic Effects of Flow on Corrosion Prediction.

Lotz U., and Henz E. 1983. WerkstKorros. 34: 454.

Berger P. F., and HauK. F. 1997. International Journal Heat Transfer. 20: 1185.

API 17D Specification for Subsea Wellhead and Christmas Tree Equipment.

UK HSE/TUV-NEL. 2003. Erosion Research Report 115.

Shreir L. L. 1994. Corrosion Handbook. Butterworth Heineman. 3rd Edition.

DNV Offshore Standard-Submarine Pipeline Systems OS-F 101 (2000).

Federal Registrar – DOI/MMS Proposed Rules- 30 CFR parts 250, 253, 254 and 256 (2007).

Fontana M. G. and Greene N. D. 2000. Corrosion Engineering. McGraw Hill orig. pub. 1967, re-publish.

Czajkowski C. Z. 1987. Metallugical Evaluation of an 18 inch Feedwater Line Failure at the Surry unit Power Station.

Dooley K. B. 2010. Flow Accelerated Corrosion in Fissile and Combined Cycle/HRSG Plants Power Plant Chemical. 10: 68.

Fujiwara K., Domae M., Ohira T. 2011. Electrochemical Measurements Carbon Steel under high Flow Rate condition and Thermodynamic solubility of Iron. Inc. Proceeding of the 16th Pacific Basin Nuclear Conference.

Shunsuke U., etal. 2011. Evaluation of Flow Accelerated Corrosion by Coupled Analysis of Corrosion and Flow Dynamics. Relationship of Oxide Film Thickness, Hematite/Magnetite Ratio, ECP and Wall Thinning Rate.

Nyborg A. R., et al. 2010. Corrosion and Water Condensation Rates in Wet Gas Pipelines ,paper 07554 NACE Corrosion.

Waterhouse I. R. 2008. Developments in Spray Pig Inhibitor Application. The Pipeline Pigging and Integrity Management Conference, Houston.

Andersen T. R., et al. 2007. The Influence of Condensation Rate and Acetic Concentration on tol Corrosion in Multiphase Pipelines, paper 07312 NACE Corrosion.

Vitse F. S., et al. 2003. Mechanistic Model for the prediction of the Line Corrosion Risk, paper 03633.

API 580 Risk-based Inspection, Recommended Practice, First Edition May (2002).

Derrick O. N., Michael F. 2012. Modelling of Pipe bend erosion by Dilute Particle Suspensions.

Ablert K. L. 1994. Effects of Particle Impingement Angle and Surface Wetting on Solid Particle Erosion of AISI 1018 Steel,Tuis, OK.

Badr H. M., et al. 2003. Numerical Investigationerosion Threshold Velocity with Sudden Contraction Computers Fluids.

Badr H. M, et al. 2006. Erosion in The Tube Entrance Region of an Air-cooled Heat Exchanger. International Journal of Impact Engineering. 3291: 1440–1463.

Bergevin K. 1984. Effect of slurry velocity on the Mechanical and Electro-chemical components of erosion-corrosion in vertical pipes (M.sc. thesis) University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada.

Bitter J. G. A. 1963a. A study of Erosion Phenomena: Part 1. Wear. 6(1): 5–21.

Bitter J. G. 1963b. A. A Study of Erosion Phenomena: Part 2. Wear. 6(3): 169–190.

Bourgoyme A. T. 1984. Experimental study of erosion in diverter systems due to sand production, Paper presented at the SPE/IADC drilling conference, SPE/IADC 18716, New Orleans, LA.

Chen X. H., Mclaury B. S. and Shirat S. A. 2004. Application and Experimental Validation Of A Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)-Based Erosion Prediction Model in Elbows and Plugged Tees. Computers and Fluids. 33(10): 1251–1272.

Chen. X. H., et al. 2006a. A Comprehensive Procedure to Estimate Erosion in Elbows for Gas/Liquid/Sand Multiphase Flow. Journal of Energy Resources Technology. 128(1): 70–78.

Chen. X. H., et al. 2006b. Numerical and Experimental Investigation of the Relative Erosion Severity Between Plugged Tees and Elbows in Dilute Gas/Solid Two Phase Flow. Wear. 261(7-8): 715–729.

Dianat M., et al. 1996. Reynolds Stress Closure Applied to Axisymmetric, Impinging Turbulent Jets. Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics. 8(6): 435–447.

Edwards J. K., McLury R. S. 1998. Supplementing a CFD Code with Erosion Prediction Capabilities. American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)Fluid Engineering Division Summer Conference, paper FEDSM 98-5229 Washington, DC.

Edwards J. K., et al. 2001. Modelling solid particle erosion in elbows and plugged tees. Journal of Energy Resources Technology. 123(4): 227–284.

Eyler R. 1987. Design and Analysis of a Pneumatic Flow Loop (M.sc. thesis). West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV.

Fan J. R., et al. 2004. Large eddy simulation of the anti-erosion characteristics of the ribbed–bend in gas-solid flows. Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power. 126(3): 672–679.

Meng H. C. and Ludema K. C. 1996. Wear Models and Predictive Equations. Their Form and Current Content. Wear. 181–183(2): 443–457.

Wang J., Shirazi S., Shadley J. and Rybick E. 1996. Application of Flow Modelling and Particle Tracking to Predict Sand Erosion Rates in Elbows. ASME Fluids Engineering Division. 236: 725–735.

Forder A., A. 2000. Computational Fluid Dynamics Investigation Into the Particulate Erosion of Oilfield Control Valves (Ph.D. thesis) University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.

Forder A., et al. 1998. A Numerical Investigation of Solid Particle Erosion Experienced within Oilfield Control Valves. Wear. 216(2): 184–193 ().

Grant G. and Tabakoff W. 1973. An Experimental Investigation of the Erosion Characteristics of 2004 Aluminium Alloy (Tech. rep. 73-37), Cincimati: Department of Aerospace Engineering University of Cincimati.

Fan J. R., et al. 1998. Numerical Investigation of a New Protection Method of the Tube Herosion by Particles Impingement. Wear. 223(1–2): 50–52.

Habib M. A., Badr H. M., Said S. A. M., Ben-Mansur R. and Al-Anizu S. S. 2006. Solid Particle Erosion in the Tube End of the Tube Sheet of a Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger. International Journal for Numerical methods in fluids. 50(8): 885–909.

Fan J., Sun P., Zhang X., and Cen K. 1999. A numerical study of a protection technique against tube erosion. Wear. 223–229: 458–464.

Fan J. R., Yan J. and Cen K. F. 2002. Anti-erosion ina 90 Degrees Bend by Particle Impaction. AICHE Journal. 48(8): 1401–1412.

Fan J., Zhang X. and Cen. K. 2001. Experimental and Numerical Investigation of a New Method for Protecting Bends from Erosion in Gas-Particle Flows. Wear. 251(1–12): 853–860.

Fan J., and et al. 1997. New Stochastic Particle Dispersion Modelling of a Turbulent Particle-laden Round Jet. Chemical Engineering Journal. 66(3): 207–215.

Fan J., Zhang D. D., Jin J. and Cen K. 1991. Numerical Simulation of Tube Erosion by Particle Impaction. Wear. 142(1): 1–10.

Finnie I. 2000. Erosion of surfaces by solid particles. Wear. 3(2): 87–103.

Finnie I. 1995. Some reflections on the past and future of erosion. Wear. 186–187(1): 1–10.

Jun Y. D. and Tabakoff W. 1994. Numerical-simulation of a Dilute Particulate Flow (Laminar) over Tube Banks. Journal of fluids Engineering. 116(4): 770–777.

Moris Y. S., et al. 2004. Principal Characteristics of Turbulent Gas-Particulate Flow in the Vicinity of Single Tube and Tube Bundle Structure. Chemical Engineering Science. 59(15): 3141–3157.

Zhang Y.,Reuterfor E. P., McLaury B. S., Shirazi S. A. and Rybicki E. F. 2007. Comparism of Computed and Measured Particle Velocities and Erosion in Water snd Air Flows. Wear. 263: 330–338.

Zhang Y., McLaury B. S., Shirazi S. A. 2009. Improvement of Particle Near-wall Velocity and Erosion Predictions Using a Commercial CFD Code. Journal of Fluids Engineering. 13(3): 031303– 031309.

Zhang Y., McLaury B. S., Shirazi S. A., and Rhbick E. F. 2010. Atwo-dimensional mechanistic model for sand erosion prediction including particle impact characteristics, in NACE international annual conference, CORROSION 2010 (paper No. 10378) San Antonio TX.

Li G., Wang Y., He R., Cao X., Lin C., and Meng T. 2009. Numerical Simulation of Predicting snd Reducjng Solid Particle Erosion of Solid-Liquid Two-phase Flow in a Choke. Petroleum Science. 6(1): 91–97.

Menguturk M. and Sverdrup E. F. 1979. Calculated tolerance electric utility gas turbine to erosion damage by coal gas ash particles. In W. F., Alder (Ed). Erosion prevention and useful application (Pp 193-224), Philadelphia; American Society for Testing and Materials, ASTM-STP-664.

Njubuenwu D. O., Fairweather M. and Yao J. 2012. Prediction of turbulent gas-solid flow in a duct with a 900 bend using an Eulerian-Lagangian Approach. AIChE Journal. 58(1): 14–30.

IONIK-J P Kenny Reports, Internal Spreadsheets and Toolbxes(2005-2008).

Singh B., et al. 2005. Risk, Rust and Reliability, paper 05553, NACE Corrosion.

Nyborg R., Dugstad A. 2003. Understanding and Prediction of Mesa Corrosion Attack, paper 03642, NACE Corrosion.

Olsen S., 2003. CO2 Corrosion Prediction by Use of Norsok M506 Model, Guidelines and limitations, paper 03623, NACE Corrosion.




How to Cite

Md Sheriff, J., Muhammadu, M. M., & Hamzah, E. (2013). Effect of Flow Pattern at Pipe Bends on Corrosion Behaviour of Low Carbon Steek and its Challenges. Jurnal Teknologi, 63(1). https://doi.org/10.11113/jt.v63.1123



Science and Engineering