Theoretical Framework of Collaborative Design Issues
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.11113/jt.v70.3577Keywords:
Collaborative design, design management, knowledge management, collaborationAbstract
Building’s design is developing to involve complexities of engineering systems, where design process requires various disciplines of participants to solve the complex issues. Collaborative design is developed with main purpose to facilitate the integration of multiple participants in design process to produce best design. This paper presents conceptual understanding, current practices, and theoretical framework of collaborative design. Literature review builds the conceptual understanding, exploratory study through in-depth interviews to design managers and designers reveals the current practices, and grounded theory constructs the theoretical framework. The review had found three main indicators of collaborative design, and through those indicators it has been identified that collaborative design is implemented at design process. The interviews had revealed that best design is hard to be achieved although collaborative design has been applied. Through grounded theory analysis, it has been found that the lack understanding of Knowledge Management (KM) roles is found to be main issue collaborative design practices.
References
Rahmawati, Y., N. Anwar, C. Utomo. 2013. A Concept of Successful Collaborative Design towards Sustainability of Project Development. International Journal of Social, Human Science & Engineering. 7(4). ISSN: 1307-6892.
Majid, A., H. Lamit, A. Keyvanfar, A. Shafaghat. 2012. Conceptual Intelligent Building (IB) Design Framework to Improve the Level of User Comfort Towards Sustainable Energy Efficient Strategies: Proposal Validation. OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development. 4(1): 11–18.
Patel, H., M. Pettitt, and J. R. Wilson. 2012. Factors of Collaborative Working: A Framework For A Collaboration Model. Applied Ergonomics. 43: 1–26.
Rashvand, P., M. Z. A. Majid, K. Yahya, R. M. Zin, R. Zakaria. 2013. Critical Review on The Customer Satisfaction Metrics for Project Success in Construction. Advanced Science Letter. 19(10): 3014–3016.
Favela, J., K. Imai, and J. J Connor. 1994. Hypermedia Support For Collaborative Design. Design Studies. 15(1): 45–58.
Kvan, T. 2000. Collaborative Design: What Is It?. Automation in Construction. 9: 409–415.
Rahmawati, Y., C. Utomo, and N. Anwar. 2012. Collaborative Design in Construction: Past, Present, and Future Research. International Conference of Sustainable Built Environment. 10–12 July 2012, Yogyakarta.
Utomo, C., and Y. Rahmawati. 2012. The Achievement to Sustainability on Vertical Housing Development through Whole System Design. 3rd International Seminar on Tropical Eco Settlements. 31 October 2012, Jakarta.
Bedwell, W. L., J. L. Wildman, D. DiazGranados, M. Salazar, W. S. Kramer, and E. Salas. 2012. Collaboration at Work: An Integrative Multilevel Conceptualization. Human Resource Management Review.
Peng, C. 1994. Exploring Communication in Collaborative Design: Co-operative Architectural Modelling. Design Studies. 15(1): 19–44.
Lu, S. C. Y., W. Elmaraghy, G. Schuh, and R. Wilhelm. 2007. A Scientific Foundation of Collaborative Engineering. Annals of the CIRP. 56(2): 605–634.
Liu, H., M. Tang, and J. H. Frazer. 2004. Supporting Dynamic Management in a Multi Agent Collaborative Design System. Journal of Advance in Engineering Software. 35: 493–502.
Detienne, F. 2006. Collaborative Design: Managing Task Interdependen-cies and Multiple Perspective. Interacting With Computer. 18: 1–20.
Chiu, M. L. 2002. An Organization View of Design Communication in Design Collaborative. Design Studies. 23: 187–210.
Chiu, M. L., J. H. Lan. 2005. Information and IN-formation, Information Mining for Supporting Collaborative Design. Automation in Construction 14: 197–205.
Vivacqua, A.S., A.C.B. Garcia, and A. Gomes. 2011. BOO: Behavior-Oriented Ontology To Describe Participant Dynamic In Collocated Design Meetings. Journal Of Expert System With Application. 38: 1139–1147.
Rezgui, Y., S. Boddy, M. Wetherill, and G. Cooper. 2011. Past, Present and Future of Information and Knowledge Sharing in the Construction Industry: Towards Semantic Service-based E-construction? Computer-Aided Design. 43: 502–515.
Utomo, C, A. Idrus, and M. Napiah. 2009. Methodology for Multi Criteria Group Decision and Negotiation Support on Value-based Decision. International Conference on Advanced Computer Control. 22–24 January 2009, Singapore.
Ren, Z., F. Yang, N. M. Bouchlaghem, and C. J. Anumba. 2011. Multi-disciplinary Collaborative Building Design-A Comparative Study Between Multi-agent Systems and Multi Disciplinary Optimization Approaches. Automation in Construction. 20: 537–549.
Sebastian, R. 2007. Managing Collaborative Design, Dissertation, TU Delft University, Netherland.
Rahmawati, Y., C. Utomo. N. Anwar, P. Setijanti, and C. B. Nurcahyo. 2014. An Empirical Model for Successful Collaborative Design towards Sustainable Project Development. Journal of Sustainable Development. 7(1).
Lu, I. M., and M. M. Mantei. 1993. Managing Design Ideas with a Shared Drawing Tool. Interacting with Computers. 5: 79–114.
Gabriel, G. C., and M. L. Maher. 2002. Coding and Modelling Communication in Architectural Collaborative Design. Automation in Construction. 11: 199–211.
Gross, M. D., E. Y. L. Do, R. J. McCall, W. V. Citrin, P. Hamill, A. Warmack, and K. S. Kuczun, 1998. Collaboration and Coordination in Architectural Design: Approaches to Computer Mediated Teamwork. Automation in Construction. 7: 465–473.
Ghods, M., H. Najafpour, H. Lamit, N. Abdolahi, M. S. F. Rosley. 2014. Evaluation of the Effective Factors on Online Internet Usage in Organization. Life Science Journal. 11(1): 58–63.
Kolarevic, B., G. Schmitt, U. Hirschberg, D. Kurmann, and B. Johnson. 2000. An Experiment in Design Collaboration. Automation in Construction. 9: 73–81.
Nam, T. J., and D. Wright. 2001. The Development and Evaluation of Syco3D: A Real-time Collaborative 3D CAD system. Design Studies. 22: 557–582.
Craig, D. L., and C. Zimring. 2002. Support for Collaborative Design Reasoning in Shared Virtual Spaces. Automation in Construction. 11: 249–259.
McCall, R., and E. Johnson. 1997. Using Argumentative Agents to Catalyze and Support Collaboration in Design. Automation in Construction. 6: 299–309.
Anumba, C. J., O. O. Ugwu, L. Newnham, and A. Thorpe. 2002. Collaborative Design of Structures using Intelligent Agents. Automation in Construction. 11: 89–103.
Li, W. D., W. F. Lu, J. Y. H. Fuh, and Y. S. Wong. 2005. Collaborative Computer Aided Design–research and Development Status. Computer Aided Design. 37: 931–940.
Haymaker, J., P. Keel, E. Ackermann, and W. Porter. 2000. Filter Mediated Design: Generating Coherence in Collaborative Design. Design Studies. 21: 205–220.
Bock, C., X. F. Zha, H.W. Suh, and J. H Lee. 2010. Ontological Product Modeling for Collaborative Design. Advanced Engineering Informatics. 24: 510–524.
Mezher, T., M. A. Abdul-Malak, I. Ghosani, and M. Ajam. 2005. Knowledge Management in Mechanical and Industrial Engineering Consulting: A Case Study. Journal of Management in Engineering. 21(3).
Leeuwen, J. P. V., and S. Fridqvist. 2006. An Information Model for Collaboration in the Construction Industry. Computers in Industry. 57: 809–816.
Lottaz, C, I. F. C. Smith, Y. R. Nicoud, and B. V. Faltings. 2000. Constraint-based Support for Negotiation in Collaborative Design. Artificial Intelligent in Engineering. 14: 261–280.
Kalay, Y. E., L. Khemlani, and J. W. Choi. 1998. An Integrated Model to Support Distributed Collaborative Design of Buildings. Automation in Construction. 7: 177–188.
Yadollahi, M., R. Anzari, M. Z. A. Majid, C. H. Yih. 2014. A Multi-Criteria Analysis for Bridge Sustainability Assessment: A Case Study of Penang Second Bridge, Malaysia. Sructure and Infrastructure Engineering. 1–17. DOI: 10.1080/15732479.2014.893002.
McCall, R., and E. Johnson. 1997. Using Argumentative Agents to Catalyze and Support Collaboration in Design. Automation in Construction. 6: 299–309.
Lamit, H., A. Shafaghat, M. Z. A. Majid, A. Keyvanfar, M. H. Ahmad, T. A. Malik. 2013. Grounded Group Decision Making (GGDM) Model. Advanced Science Letter. 19(10): 3077–3080.
Keyvanfar, A., M. Z. A. Majid, A. Shafaghat, H. Lamit, A. Talaiekhozan, M. W. Hussin, C. T. Lee, R. B. M. Zin, M. A. Fulazzaky. 2013. Application of a Grounded Group Decision-making (GGDM) Model: A Case of Micro-organism Optimal Inoculation Method in Biological Self-healing Concrete. Desalination and Water Treatment. 52(19): 3594–3599.
Lamit, H., M. Z. A. Majid, A. Shafaghat, A. Keyvanfar. 2012. Sidewalk Design Decision Making Model Based on Walking Behavior Pattern Recognition: Proposal Validation. OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Development. 4(1): 27–34.
Girard, P., and V. Robin. 2006. Analysis of Collaboration for Project Design Management. Computers in Industry. 57: 817–826.
Majid, M. Z. A., W. Z. Zakaria, H. Lamit, A. Keyvanfar, A. Shafaghat, E. S. Bakti. 2012. Construction Information Systems for Executive Management in Monitoring Work Progress. Advanced Science Letter. 15(1): 169–171.
Davenport, T.H., and L. Prusak. 1998. Working Knowledge: How Organizations Manage What They Know. Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
Robin V., B. Rose, and P. Girard. 2006. Modelling Collaborative Knowledge to Support Engineering Design Project Manager. Computers in Industry. 58: 188–198.
Adnan, A., R. Zakaria, C. K. Wah, A. L. Saleh, K. Yahya, M. Mustaffar, M. R. A. Shakri. 2012. Decision Making Framework for Earthquake Resistant Building. Advanced Science Letter. 13: 827–830.
Ping, C. S., C. N. Y. Keung, and M. Ramanathan. 2011. Integrated Team Design Process–successful Stories of Hong Kong MTR Corporation Projects. Journal of Procedia Engineering. 14: 1190–1196.
Huan, R., S. Kahai, and R. Jestice. 2010. The Contingent Effects of Leadership on Team Collaboration in Virtual Teams. Computers in Human Behavior. 26: 1098–1110.
Adams, R., S. R. Daly, L. M. Mann, and G. Dall’Alba. 2011. Being a Professional: Three Lenses into Design Thinking, Acting, and Being. Design Studies. 32: 588–607.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright of articles that appear in Jurnal Teknologi belongs exclusively to Penerbit Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (Penerbit UTM Press). This copyright covers the rights to reproduce the article, including reprints, electronic reproductions, or any other reproductions of similar nature.
